Erasing the Past

As a result of its multiple violations, the NCAA denied the University of Louisville’s appeal and vacated numerous men’s college basketball victories from 2011-2015. Among those vacated victories are Louisville’s 2012 Final Four appearance and their 2013 NCAA Championship. In essence, the Louisville Cardinals basketball team was nonexistent.

I find the NCAA’s ruling completely ridiculous. Vacating wins is one of the stupidest sanctions in collegiate sports. Despite the NCAA’s best efforts, everybody knows who won the games and who was one of the better teams in the nation during that span of time. I am in no way defending the actions of the university. They were in blatant violation of the NCAA’s rules and had to face the music as a result. Vacating wins was not the right way of going about the situation though.

I feel like the NCAA should have banned the Cardinals from postseason play for a long time, fine them, and take away multiple scholarships. That would hurt the university financially and from a recruiting standpoint. Vacating wins, however, does nothing. In my opinion, it does more harm than good. It punishes the fans who support the team. It punishes the players, coaches, and team officials who had nothing to do with the scandal. It also makes the NCAA look ignorant by ignoring what is on record.

The university had to take down its 2012 Final Four banner and its 2013 National Championship banner as well as return the 2013 National Championship trophy. The players will still have their rings. Rick Pitino will still have his championship tattoo (unless he decides to get it removed.) Fans will still have championship memorabilia from that season. Despite the NCAA’s best efforts, everybody who does not live under a rock will always know that the University of Louisville won those basketball games, made it to the Final Four in 2012, and had their one shining moment in 2013. As I write this post, a new NCAA scandal is on the verge of taking down some of the biggest names in college basketball. What will the NCAA do? If I had to guess, it’ll try to rewrite history.